English home · Practice areas · News · Enquire · Deutsch
This page concerns German law and applicable EU rules. Foreign-law questions require separate assessment.
Keeping, transport and treatment allegations may trigger criminal and administrative-offence proceedings. We assess the allegation and evidence. Parallel veterinary authority measures require separate treatment.
Potential allegations
Section 17 TierSchG covers specified conduct towards vertebrates, particularly killing without reasonable cause and defined cases of substantial pain or suffering. Not every keeping error meets this offence. Administrative offences, including section 18, are distinct. Conservation, health, transport and medicine rules, and offences such as negligent bodily injury after an animal accident, may also apply.
Investigations and file access
Suspects need not comment on the allegations. Before a substantive statement, examine allegations, files and veterinary assessments. Care, task allocation and chronology may be decisive. Preserve documents and evidence unchanged.
Searches, securing evidence and seizure
We assess the legal basis and remedies. For animals, accommodation, care and condition records must also be addressed. Criminal-procedure seizure differs from administrative removal.
Fine notices and penal orders
An objection to a fine notice is generally due to the issuing authority within two weeks of service under section 67 OWiG. A penal order generally has the same period, with objection to the issuing court under section 410 StPO. Check scope, form and deadline against the document.
Trial, experts and appeals
Trial examines witnesses, findings and reports. Welfare allegations may turn on the nature, duration, cause and severity of suffering. Depending on the decision, appeal on facts or law, or a complaint on law in fine proceedings, may be available. Admissibility is not automatic.
Businesses, management and ancillary consequences
Distinguish individual responsibility, supervision and organisation. Alongside fines or imprisonment, confiscation and other statutory consequences may arise. Permits and professional consequences require parallel review. We also advise on appropriate records and preventing further breaches.
Legal foundations
Section 17 TierSchG · Section 67 OWiG · Section 410 StPO
Preparing for advice
Send a short chronology, names and key documents. Identify deadlines and service dates expressly. We first clarify conflicts, scope and fees.
In depth: procedural goals, evidence and commercial consequences
Before choosing procedure, identify the goal: resisting or enforcing a claim, retaining permission or stopping immediate action. The dispute and acting party determine the route. A civil claim does not replace a challenge to an administrative act. Discontinued criminal investigations do not automatically resolve contractual or regulatory disputes.
Identifying and addressing disputes early
Prospects often depend on provable facts. Organise documents, witnesses, findings and timing. A private expert report can support a case but is not automatically equivalent to a court-appointed report. Preservation may be urgent where health changes, sale is planned or premises are altered. Animal care must remain secured.
Four practical examples
The following scenarios are illustrative, not accounts of actual instructions or promised outcomes. Legal assessment depends on the facts that can be established.
1. Summons after a welfare complaint
A keeper is asked to comment. First clarify procedural role, file evidence and whether to make a statement. A spontaneous comprehensive account can create difficult inconsistencies.
2. Fine after transport inspection
A carrier disputes the breach. Check service, objection, measurements and responsibility. Authority discussions do not replace timely formal action.
3. Search of breeding premises
Documents and animals are secured. Assess basis, scope and remedies separately. Care and document handling remain immediate practical concerns.
4. Penal order for negligence
An accident leads to a fine by penal order. Assess allegation, evidence and objection risks, including implications for permits and professional activity.
Documents, evidence and next steps
Costs, duration, enforcement and further proceedings inform strategy. Settlement may resolve matters faster but should specify performance, payment, handover and scope. Appeals require review of deadlines, admissibility, grounds and representation. Full pleadings, service records and chronology are essential.